| Platinum | 3 Tequilas |
| Gold | Little Knight's Taco Truck |
| Silver | Ted's Cafe Escondido |
| Bronze | Hidalgo's Mexican Restaurant & Cantina |
| Top Pick | Agave Azul |
| Top Pick | Chico's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Cowboy Chicken |
| Top Pick | Los Acros Mexican Restaurant Danforth Square |
| Top Pick | Los Arcos Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sinaloa Signature Restaurante |