| Platinum | Hideaway Pizza |
| Gold | Jo's Famous Pizza |
| Silver | Empire Slice House |
| Bronze | Woodward Pizza |
| Top Pick | All American Pizza |
| Top Pick | Dan's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hobby's Hoagies |
| Top Pick | Mio Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Oak City Pizza |
| Top Pick | Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza |